Influence of the solvent representation on vibrational entropy calculations: Generalized born versus distance-dependent dielectric model

The harmonic model is the most popular approximation for estimating the "configurational" entropy of a solute in molecular mechanics/Poisson-Boltzmann solvent accessible surface area (MM/PBSA)-type binding free energy calculations. Here, we investigate the influence of the solvent representation in the harmonic model by comparing estimates of changes in the vibrational entropies for 30 trypsin/ligand complexes on ligand binding. Second derivatives of Amber generalized Born (GB) solvation models are available in the nucleic acid builder code. They allow one to use these models for the calculation of vibrational entropies instead of using a simpler solvation model based on a distance-dependent dielectric (DDD) constant. Estimates of changes in the vibrational entropies obtained with a DDD model are systematically and significantly larger, by on average, 6 kcal mol(-1) (at T = 300 K), than estimates obtained with a GB model and so are more favorable for complex formation. The difference becomes larger the more the vibrational entropy contribution disfavors complex formation, that is, the larger the ligand is (for the complexes considered here). A structural decomposition of the estimates into per-residue contributions reveals polar interactions between the ligand and the surrounding protein, in particular involving charged nitrogens, as a main source of the differences. Snapshots minimized with the DDD model showed a structural deviation from snapshots minimized in explicit water that is larger by, on average, 0.5 Å RMSD compared to snapshots that were minimized with GB(HCT) . As experimental vibrational entropies of biomacromolecules are elusive, there is no direct way to establish a solvent model's superiority. Thus, we can only recommend using the GB harmonic model for vibrational entropy calculations based on the reasoning that smaller structural deviations should point to the implicit solvent model that closer approximates the energy landscape of the solute in explicit solvent.